Warning to non-baseball dorks, this post is boring. Also, warning to baseball dorks...same warning. Just humor me, okay? Okay.
In the course of a fantasy season, everyone makes mistakes. Sometimes, they don't poison your team to the point of suck saturated. Other times, like my team in a 20 team league with my chums at
protrade.com, your team is internet death. The fact I can already pinpoint 10 CONSIDERABLE mistakes ought to reveal my propensity to suck at fantasy sports.
Some ground rules!!!!!!!!!
These are not ranked in any particular order. I will give each item a "brain cells lost" rating on a one to five scale. The dumber the move, the higher the rating. Also, note that these are mistakes as of 5-25-09. There are players listed here who could rebound, as well as players I cannot afford to give up. Want an example? Let's start with #10.
10. Drafting Corey Hart in the 3rd Round:
I considered this guy a lock for 40 doubles, 20 homers, and 20 stolen bases. Still do, really. Totally ignored his 27BB/109K stinktastic in '08! Oddly enough, he's improved his plate discipline and already has 19 walks, improving his OBP from last year: .300 to .322. Paltry pants.
But I'm not alone here. Baseball Prospectus ranked him the
#1 right fielder. Right above Nick Markakis (who I drafted in the second round....that's right, two OFs in the first three rounds). Corey Hart is currently on pace for a .245/.322/.399 with 15 homers and 11 stolen bases
AND HUZZAH 40 DOUBLES. I think he will rebound, but as a reference point, the thus far superior Andre Ethier was taken in Round 6.
Rating: 2 brain cells lost out of 5. If BP gets it wrong, I'll follow them off the cliff.
9. Dropping Todd Helton:
I added Todd Helton on April 2nd, needing a decent utility after trading Nick Markakis for CC Sabathia. I dropped him on April 13th, IN A LEAGUE WITH A TRANSACTION LIMIT, I GAVE UP ON HIM AFTER ONLY SIX GAMES. God, I am stupid. Why am I so stupid, God?
On April 13th, Helton was batting .150/.217/.150 with no homers. Now he is batting .342/.392/
.537 with six homers. Colossal.
Rating: 5 brain cells lost out of 5. Even worse considering my first base options are feces farmer Mike Jacobs and sack of nothing, unibrow, ADD sufferer Adam LaRoche. THIS MAKES ME ANGRY EVERY DAY I WAKE UP.
8. Trading Jayson Werth for Adam LaRoche and Jesus Flores:
I like Jesus Flores. He saved me from catcher limbo (aka Gerald Laird). But this is a keeper league, and no one keeps a catcher. Werth, on the other hand, is a good source of speed and power, and has eligibility at all outfield positions. He's the prototypical middle round keeper, finally getting his licks at the decent age of 30.
My hatred for Adam LaRoche is archived. Why did I trade for him? This is not a rhetorical question. Right now, the clown has eight more strikeouts than hits. Am I being harsh? No. If you are an Adam LaRoche fan, go in a corner and pray he reads this, takes his ADD medicine so he can focus on finding me, finds me, and kills me. The grammar in the previous sentence seems forced.
Mike Jacobs is Mickey Mantle compared to this unibro.
Rating: 3 out of 5. Love Flores too much to go higher.
7. Drafting Jeff Clement:
Side effects of researching your fantasy draft prospects may include:
1. Hoping for too much.
2. Thinking you're smarter than you actually are.
3. Drafting Jeff Clement.
I drafted this Seattle catching prospect, in the 11th round of a 17 round draft, thinking he may make a quick minor league impression and join the team sooner than later. Well, he's still in the minors, and is hitting well as he's always done in the minors. Problem is, I can't sit on him in a league with three bench slots. Not doing it for a catching prospect. Wouldn't be Clement. (This is a veiled attempt at parodying Dana Carvey's "Wouldn't be Prudent," fail)
I'd also note that every year I do this. I try to get cute drafting a catcher, avoiding the overvalued Joe Mauers and Russell Martins of the world. I'd say it bites me in the ass 85% of the time. In this particular draft, Jarrod Saltalamacchia was taken two rounds later, Kurt Suzuki three rounds. D'oh.
Rating: 3 out of 5. He'll make an impact eventually. I overrated him
but good.
6. Drafting Brad Lidge in the fifth round. Not drafting anymore closers after that:
At this point I'm employing drastic measures to fix my team, a team that's currently 16th out of 20 with a 31-43-17 record. I've made an executive decision to give up saves, made that much more easier by Lidge's mental midgetry and mound gascan. Instead, I will employ more high K/9 starters in good matchups to try and take the remaining categories (ERA, WHIP, Ws, Ks). Holds can go to hell.
I don't believe drafting Brad Lidge was a huge mistake. I heard "he's due to blow up," but as we all know, there's no such thing as "being due." There are career proclivities however, and Lidge is reverting back to his 2006 and 2007 form, when he was 51 for 65 in save opportunities. In 2006 he had a 1.40 WHIP, his worst. This year he has a 2.08 WHIP. WHAT TO DO?
I traded him for Coco Crisp to replace Werth at the everday CF spot. You might be saying, Coco Crisp? Remember, I'm giving up on saves. Soon, I'm giving up on my team. This is not the future my mother warned me about.
Rating: 1 out of 5. This is more of a fantasy philosophical sea change than my unmatched stupidity.
5. Wasting Transactions on the Following Players: Andy LaRoche, Gerald Laird, Joe Thurston, Jody Gerut, Pat Burrell, Ryan Sweeney, Cody Ross, Ryan Spillborghs, Laynce Nix, Dallas Braden, Manny Parra:
Not all of these players are terrible, but what they all have in common is a minimal impact to my team. Minimal is putting it mildly, as none of them are still on my team. Some of these players I never started. This represents 11 wasted pickups through 25% of the season in a league with a limit of 50 transactions.
I've made 20 total transactions and only five have helped: Paul Maholm (his days are numbered), Alberto Callaspo (flavor of the month?), Jorge De La Rosa (high K/9), Michael Cuddyer (the crown jewel), and J.A. Happ (still pending).
If I was paid to do this, I'd be fired on the spot, sirs.
Rating: 4 out of 5. It would be five, but there's impulse involved in this too, not just stupidity.
4. Drafting Matt Thornton:
I'm morally opposed to holds. No one wants to waste a spot for middle relief, or waste a transaction for a cheap fantasy win. But, their inclusion helps balance the importance of pitching with hitting, so I'll bite my internet tongue and cope.
So why would I even draft a guy that produces nothing but holds? I don't know. Probably my HMO lobotomy.
Rating: 1 out of 5. He was my last pick. No biggie. The damn computer drafted Juan Pierre while I was on the John, so that was more frustrating. Barry Zito was drafted right after Thornton, followed by Dallas McPherson. Not like I missed out on gold mines.
3. I've never been in a keeper league:
Never!!!!!!!
We get to keep four players. I don't know how to draft with keeper league tendencies, or if keeper league tendencies were even necessary. But I drafted with clenched fist and anus in full panic mode because of these conditions.
We get to keep four players. I don't know if my list of keepers makes sense (Kinsler, Billingsley, Choo..............Cuddyer?) Am I supposed to keep sleepers or my studs? It would seem silly to keep a stud and waste what could be a better first round player! ACKKKKKK, WHAT DO I DO? SURROUNDED BY KEEPER LEAGUE EXPERTS.
Rating: 0 out of 5. It's a list of ten things. Expect at least one stretch.
2. Dropping Ryan Theriot:
I still don't think Ryan Theriot is that good (currently 2 for his last 24 with no Rs and no RBIs),
but I dropped him in favor of Alberto Callaspo, who's only good for doubles. When Theriot is on the right side of his streaks, he's good for speed, average, and runs on a team that's powerful when healthy.
He was a little too singles happy for my liking, so I gave up and dropped him on April 29th. He hit no homers in April. BUT HE HIT FIVE HOMERS IN MAY. Although, in fairness to me, in spite of the world being against it, his May numbers are .205/.279/.487. More doubles and homers, but too much major slumpage. I'd rather have Theriot than Callaspo, but the dropoff isn't too drastic.
Rating: 2 out of 5. Meh.
1. Drafting Armando Galarraga:
He sucks. I know he sucks. He's sneaky at his suckage. Fluke. Fluke. Fluke.
ALL OF THE STATS POINTED TO THIS. I was told by smart people not to draft this guy. I drafted this guy. He started well, now he could possibly
LOSE HIS GIG when Bondermann returns. Not just lose his gig, LOSE HIS GIG TO DONTRELLE WILLIS.
3-4, 5.74 ERA, 1.55 WHIP, 35 Ks, 24 BBs in 47.0 innings of diarrhea
HAS GIVEN UP EIGHT HOMERUNS IN HIS LAST FIVE STARTS.
I drafted him in Round 14. Here are some pitchers drafted after him: Jeremy Guthrie, Wandy Rodriguez, Joe Saunders, Rick Porcello, Paul Maholm. All better. All assured of their spots in the rotation.
WHAT WAS I THINKING? rating: 1,543,346,765,304 out of 5
diapers